Skip to content

Syed Hamid blamed for ISA arrest of Sin Chew reporter

Sat 2012-Dec-8 @ MYT 12:35:25 pm

Syed Hamid Albar, then home minister, had ordered the police to arrest Sin Chew Daily reporter Tan Hoon Cheng under the Internal Security Act in 2008, according to former police chief Musa Hassan in an interview with Free Malaysia Today.

He said he had scolded his deputy, Ismail Omar, for making the arrest and claims that Ismail (now the IGP) had wept and offered to resign.

Tan Hoon Cheng, a reporter with Sin Chew in Penang, was arrested in September 2008 after reporting on a speech by Umno divisional leader Ahmad Ismail who had said that Malaysian Chinese were “squatters” and did not deserve equal rights.

Hoon Cheng was arrested at about 8.30pm on Sept 12 at her home in Bukit Mertajam, sparking a loud public outcry and protests. She was released the next afternoon after being interrogated and held overnight at Penang police headquarters, and being driven to Ipoh and back.

Free Malaysia Today reported Musa Hassan as saying in an interview that the police had made the arrest in obedience to the then home minister Syed Hamid Albar. He was in hospital at the time for a heart bypass operation. He said he scolded his deputy Ismail Omar and the latter wept and offered to resign.

Syed Hamid had said at the time she had been arrested “for her own protection” and that police had acted on information of a threat on her life.

From Free Malaysia Today:

“The explanation sounded absurd to me,” Musa told FMT.

He said he told Ismail, who was acting IGP, to investigate the case under the Sedition Act and not to use the ISA to arrest anyone. He said he was upset at the turn of events and demanded an explanation from Ismail when he visited him at IJN.

“Then he started crying, saying that the minister gave the instructions. He told me he wanted to resign, saying things like ‘I want to resign, I don’t want to work anymore. “I said to him, ‘You shouldn’t be allowing yourself to be dictated to. I am in the hospital now, and you are Acting IGP.’ I told him ‘It’s stupid of you, wanting to resign. Next time, just don’t do it.’”

Asked if he tried to confront Syed Hamid, Musa said he could not because he was bedridden.

“But of course the girl was later released. But it was wrong. Using ISA didn’t make sense to me. If you think any seditious statement was made, then you have the law to investigate, right?”

During the controversy, Syed Hamid told the press the arrest was a police decision and that he had not interfered.

More recently, during the Umno annual general assembly, Syed Hamid denied Musa’s allegation that home ministers were among the politicians who regularly attempted to interfere with police investigations.
Asked to comment on this, Musa told FMT: “Well he can deny it, but Ismail told me at that time that he was directed.”

» Full report at Free Malaysia Today

About these ads
3 Comments
  1. Shadaan permalink
    Sat 2012-Dec-8 @ MYT 14:35:12 pm 14:35

    That is why you will hear people saying “Politics is a bad game of deceit and hatred”, “Politics is a do or die affair”, “Politics is a dirty business”, “and Politicians are very sick people” and so on. It is those politicians of limited merits and capabilities that are bad. Unfortunately Syed Hamid Albar, the then home minister seems to fit into that category. Constitutions are also made for the purpose of securing, protecting, promoting good governance, accountability and welfare of all citizens-the governed. Why were draconian laws like the ISA allowed to remain for so long after Independence in Malaysia? It is telling you that the government is not democratic but racially abusive and had no qualms about using it on anyone they dislike or question their race or integrity. He had put a reporter who reported on what was actually said in a speech and instead of honestly responding to defend his integrity; this incapable politician used the ISA against the reporter. That is one of the reasons why the people of Malaysia have revolted against the ruling government; it is a wakeup call against the government for all the atrocities that were committed over the years. One thing that suprised me was that the people of Malaysia took so long to stand up against bad governance and communiust kind of legislation called ISA.

  2. Sat 2012-Dec-8 @ MYT 18:52:28 pm 18:52

    @ kind of laws in Malaysia ..1 for malays and 1 for others…they did that……..

  3. Mr Bojangles permalink
    Sat 2012-Dec-8 @ MYT 20:26:52 pm 20:26

    And yet that same person was promoted to head SPAD with all the perquisites and power as tho he deserved it for stellar performance as home minister.
    Rewarding mediocrity is what BN politics is all about. And of course bending to the will of people whose main motivation is revenge and to fix those who question their actions.
    I believe that many also died from the excessive and undue force used by the police under this man’s watch as home minister.
    I just hope he has a conscience and is made to pay for all his stupidity malice and mischief.

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 734 other followers

%d bloggers like this: