Skip to content

NST says Malaysiakini, CIJ, and Loyar Burok in anti-govt coup plot

Fri 2012-Sep-21 @ +08 11:34:57 am

• Malaysiakini and three media activist groups named
• NST makes poor attempt at smear with no facts on ‘coup plot’
• Chandra Muzaffar lends voice to smear campaign

Today’s joke about fearless, open journalism. If you’ve seen this story before, drop a note below.

The NST ‘coup plot’ 11:
• Mkini Dotcom Sdn Bhd
(publishers of Malaysiakini);
• Southeast Asia Centre for e-Media (Seacem);
• Southeast Asian Press Alliance (SEAPA) based in Bangkok;
• Centre for Independent Journalism;
• Merdeka Center for Opinion Research;
• Liberal Banter Sdn Bhd (publishers of the Loyar Burok web site);
• Lawyers for Liberty;
• Bersih;
• Suaram;
US-based groups
• International Republican Institute » ;
• National Democratic Institute for International Affairs »

Malaysiakini, the Centre for Investigative Journalism, the Loyar Burok law activists, and the Merdeka Centre opinion pollsters were among 11 organisations attacked by the New Straits Times today in a thinly-disguised political smear, which accused them of being part of an anti-government coup plot.

The attack was made in a sensational front-page lead under the headline “Plot to Destabilise Govt”.

But the report, under the byline of NST Putrajaya bureau chief Farrah Naz Karim*, provides no facts on any such plot and instead relies on second-hand information to make a tenuous link between the pro-democracy activities and the downfall of dictatorships in African and Middle Eastern countries.

(A story on almost the same lines, and against the same organisations, was carried in the English-language press, probably also by the NST a year or two ago, but I cannot find the link now. Please post it below if you find it. Thanks.)

The NST story provides no details of any activities by the organisations that amount to a coup plot and relies only on a list of figures — supplied by anonymous sources — to show funding from the US-based National Endowment for Democracy, and from the George Soros-backed Open Society Institute.

Two other US-based organisations are also named in the report: the National Democratic Institute and the International Republican Institute. (On Wednesday, the two organisations presented Burmese democracy leader Aung Sang Suu Kyi with a freedom award.)

NST names Aung Sang Suu Kyi’s US supporters in Malaysian coup plot

Aung Sang Suu Kyi receiving a freedom award from former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, chairman of NDI, and US Senator John McCain, chairman of IRI, on Wednesday

None of the Malaysian organisations were quoted for their side of the story.

Instead, the story uses a Berita Harian interview with formerly well-respected political scientist Chandra Muzaffar to make a suggestive link between the NED, democracy activism, and popular uprisings in Arab countries which saw the downfall of dictatorships and tyranny.

The argument is so simplistic and so tenuous that it is laughable. It goes like this:

• The National Endowment for Democracy gives money for people to promote democracy.
• Promotion of democracy caused unrest in Arab and Muslim countries run by dictators and undemocratic governments.
• Pro-democracy movements caused these dictatorships to fall.
• The NED gave money to 8 Malaysian organisations and 3 others.
• Therefore the 11 organisations are trying to overthrow the government and replace it with a puppet government.

It is not only simplistic, it’s stupid but you can rely on pro-Umno bloggers and the pro-Umno establishment to use these “facts” to hammer away at pro-democracy movements.

Is Umno anti-democracy now?

If Umno thinks pro-democracy movements are evil, then it seems fair to say that Umno is anti-democracy and against democratic people’s movements. Does the federal government think that, too?

There is little doubt that the new smear campaign against Malaysiakini, CIJ, Loyar Burok and Merdeka Centre is linked to the current Umno-sponsored government campaign against the human rights organisation Suaram.

Umno-headed government ministries have made a open attempt to silence Suaram, which has been at the forefront of keeping alive the Scorpene and Altantuya scandals and helping in a French judicial inquiry, in which subpoenas could be issued to the Defence Minister and the Prime Minister.

• Chandra Muzaffar, a founder of Aliran, was once a highly-regarded champion of human rights and democracy but has espoused pro-establishment views since a falling out with Anwar Ibrahim and Parti Keadilan Nasional.

• Farrah Naz Karim is an award-winning journalist — she won the Best Journalist award from the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission last year, receiving a plaque and a certificate from MACC chief commissioner Abu Kassim Mohamed at the agency’s media appreciation.

(* I wonder if she had any choice in how the story was done or how it was handled.)

» Plot to destabilise govt – New Straits Times

Umno and NST type of argument: if you promote Aung Sang Suu Kyi, you must be trying to promote a revolution and therefore trying to topple the Malaysian government. Correct? But is that Umno talking, or the voice of “The Devil You Know” (a.k.a. Mahathir Mohd Kutty) who, obviously, is no fan of democracy but somehow managed to find time to meet Aung Sang Suu Kyi personally so he could look like a hero? Just like the time he engineered a photo-op with Nelson Mandela so he could look like a champion of liberty. Funny thing about pariah tyrants, they so desperately want to be liked.


  1. farha permalink
    Fri 2012-Sep-21 @ +08 12:57:06 pm 12:57

    Let’s see if NST can get lower than this.

  2. Gina permalink
    Fri 2012-Sep-21 @ +08 13:21:08 pm 13:21

    Nobody can go lower than Chandra Muzaffar … except for Ridhuan Tee abdullah, of course.

  3. nakedtothebone permalink
    Fri 2012-Sep-21 @ +08 17:37:44 pm 17:37

    Gawd!!! Communists, Jews, Christians, Singapore, Bersih, now Aung Sang Suu Kyi & frens!! The whole froicking world wants to overthrow the government and destabilize the country!! Why, why, why?? Yikes…gotta retreat back into the safety of my bunker already!!

  4. John Santiago permalink
    Thu 2012-Sep-27 @ +08 13:25:18 pm 13:25

    Chandra Muzaffar – a turncoat indeed!


  1. The NYT and the NST, from top to bottom « uppercaise

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: